JoyceRetField
Overestimation and False Alarm Incident of the Urgent Earthquake Warning
Around 12:38 PM on October 16, 2026, the Japan Meteorological Agency (JMA) issued an urgent earthquake warning for an earthquake that occurred near the Kuril Islands, initially reporting a magnitude of M6.9 with a maximum expected seismic intensity of 1. However, two minutes later, the JMA revised the magnitude to M9.9 and estimated a maximum seismic intensity of 7, issuing an earthquake alert for the entire eastern Japan region, including Hokkaido, Tohoku, Kanto, Hokuriku, Chubu, and Tokai. Eight minutes after the alert was issued, at 12:48 PM, an announcement was made that the previous urgent earthquake warning had been canceled, and a cancellation notice was broadcast. This is the first such incident where an alert was issued for a large-scale, wide area and then canceled. Here, I will organize the arguments from seismology and the JMA. First, as a premise, it is crucial that observation equipment is installed in appropriate locations for the urgent earthquake warning system. Along the coast of the Tohoku region, a large amount of equipment was installed after the Great East Japan Earthquake, achieving high precision with P-wave and S-wave arrival times and strong-motion monitor errors within 2 seconds. On the other hand, this was an earthquake originating from a distant location, the Kamchatka Peninsula, and it was a deep-focus earthquake at a depth of 160 km. Generally, it's understood that shallower earthquakes are stronger and deeper earthquakes affect a wider area. The key point is that while the earthquake in the vicinity of the Kuril Islands was observed, perfect measurement was not possible. This is a vulnerability separate from precision, and I do not believe it has reduced the credibility of the function itself.
2026.10.17 AM 1:39 · View Count 44
Join the Board and leave a comment.
Lv.1
エカ
That false alarm for the earthquake warning was quite a scare, wasn't it? Even though it was unexpected, it's crucial to always stay calm and discern accurate information. Please make sure to cherish your daily preparations and maintain peace of mind.
Lv.54
JoyceRetField
AuthorAdditional information: The Japan Meteorological Agency officially acknowledged that this incident was not a system malfunction in their automated rapid reporting system, but rather an overestimation of data processing that led to a false report. From a citizen's perspective, there are also general opinions that it's unforgivable, considering the Great East Japan Earthquake was M9.0. Such opinions are likely important in terms of the fear experienced. However, we must consider the possibility that if it had been underestimated, an earthquake of magnitude 9.9 could have actually occurred. In that case, the possibility of a distant earthquake and a massive tsunami could be a future challenge. This was the result of multiplying a massive earthquake that occurred in another country's territory by incorrect coefficients, and they have promised to prevent recurrence. Unlike past false reports, a relatively large earthquake of M6.9 actually occurred, and a seismic intensity of 1 was observed in Hakodate, far away. Paradoxically, I want to evaluate positively that they detected a massive earthquake in another country's territory and issued a warning at the rapid reporting level. I 100% agree that they should strive to improve accuracy in the future, though.

