PlayioPlayio
Go back
新・『自由』
KeeperOfMemoriesLv.51

ソウゆうコト

Was I in the wrong here…

I'd like to hear everyone's opinions on offering seats on public transport. In the past, when I tried to offer my seat to an elderly lady with good intentions, she got angry and said, "I'm not that old yet!" Since then, to avoid making others uncomfortable, I decided, "I won't offer my seat unless they ask me first." However, yesterday, while I was sitting on the train, an elderly lady standing in front of me suddenly got angry and said, "Give me your seat!" Because of my past experience, I got angry and retorted, "Don't expect me to read your mind. If you want to sit, why can't you ask first?" After that, the atmosphere in the train car became awkward, and I'm still feeling a bit uneasy. I admit my tone might have been harsh, but isn't it unreasonable to expect me to offer my seat just because I see you standing? So, regarding this incident, was I in the wrong for talking back? Please give me your honest opinions.

2026.11.15 AM 10:26 · View Count 321

11
9

Join the Board and leave a comment.

PlayoGuard helps keep the community healthy.

Lv.1

オルエル

I'm sure no one meant any harm, but perhaps we were all a little short on patience. It's important to consider others' circumstances, but expressing your honest feelings gently is also a step towards peace. Please prioritize dialogue over conflict next time.

0
2026.11.15 AM 1:29

LittleGemWallet

Lv.15

のぶどう

If you had more peace of mind, both you and that grandmother could have spoken a little more kindly, and the atmosphere wouldn't have soured. Even if the grandmother spoke harshly, I think the other person would calm down if you spoke calmly.

0
2026.11.15 AM 1:51

Focused

Lv.8

ライトニング5046

I think I agree with you... I feel like the grandmother who said 'Give up your seat' could have just gone to the priority seating area. I don't know where you were sitting, but from your writing, I assume you were in a regular seat. Then I wonder why the grandmother didn't go to the priority seats, but instead spoke to you in a regular seat. If she had gone to the priority seats, she could have been seated first as an elderly person...

0
2026.11.15 AM 2:37

Normie

Lv.20

パルファン

Hmm, maybe some people want it whispered... ❓️. Perhaps if you give them a look and gesture to a seat like 'How about this? ❓️', they might get it. Reactions like 'I'll get off next... No, wait...' are understandable... How about it? ❓️.

0
2026.11.15 AM 2:43

RegularCustomer

Lv.45

鈴木治之助

It's difficult because I don't ride crowded trains lately, so I don't encounter such situations, but I understand getting angry when an elderly woman looks down on you and speaks to you that way. However, if you had taken a deep breath and calmed down, I think you could have handled it properly. Being considerate of others is hard, but perhaps this was a good learning experience for you.

0
2026.11.15 AM 3:22

KeeperOfMemories

Lv.91

とぃとぃ

I've experienced that too. Since then, I just quietly get up and give up my seat without saying anything...

0
2026.11.15 AM 7:57