PlayioPlayio
Go back
[RE] 남들은 어떻게 생각할까? 알아보자!
TipBlackHole
Lv.111

뷩스

Do You Know the Ship of Theseus?

In his youth, the ancient Greek hero Theseus vanquished various villains on his journey to Athens, where his father resided. He defeated Sinis, who cruelly killed travelers using pine trees; Procrustes, who laid victims on his bed, cutting off the legs of those too tall and forcibly stretching the bodies of those too short; And Sciron, who sat on a cliff, forcing travelers to wash his feet before kicking them into the sea to be eaten by a giant man-eating turtle. By doing so, he became a hero of Athens. The citizens of Athens decided to preserve the ship Theseus sailed to commemorate him. Whenever an old wooden plank rotted, they replaced it with a new one. Over time, eventually, every single part of the ship was replaced without exception. This raises the first question: "Is this ship, with all its parts replaced, still the Ship of Theseus, or is it an entirely new ship?" Heraclitus believed it was a completely new ship, while Aristotle maintained it was still the same ship.

2026.11.09 PM 1:05 · View Count 95

13
3

Join the Board and leave a comment.

PlayoGuard helps keep the community healthy.
TipBlackHole

Lv.111

뷩스

Author

What do you all think? Do you still believe this ship is the Ship of Theseus, or not? Or do you have other opinions?

0
2026.11.09 AM 4:08

RNGGod

Lv.70

Lilava

These kinds of discussions are really complex and interesting. I think how it was replaced is the most important factor. If it's a new part that looks exactly the same, its appearance wouldn't change, and it would feel like it's being preserved, so I still think it's the Ship of Theseus. However, if the parts change during replacement and its form alters, I think it would be difficult to consider it the same ship. After all, when preserving something, people in the future would first see the ship and think, 'Ah, this is what the Ship of Theseus looks like.' If its form is different, it feels like they'd be learning incorrectly. I'm carefully leaving my opinion here!

1
2026.11.09 AM 4:47

Pioneer

Lv.77

푸른해골

I think it's a subjective reality. If many people believe it's the same, then it is, and if many people believe it's different, then it is.

1
2026.11.09 AM 5:05

Lv.41

나나9219

On top of that, another scenario is presented. Someone gathered all the discarded original wooden planks and rebuilt the exact same ship. Now there are two ships. 1. The ship with parts replaced one by one from the original ship. 2. The ship rebuilt with the original parts. Which one is the true Ship of Theseus? LOL We had a crazy debate about this in law philosophy class, linking it with commercial law. I still don't know. Whoever wins, that's our side!

1
2026.11.09 AM 11:06