PlayioPlayio
Go back
애니 보드
CommunityDwellerLv.13

규현킴

What are your thoughts?

What anime do you think didn't live up to its original manga? Let me know your opinions! Personally, I think Berserk and MHA ㅎㅎ

2026.11.10 PM 10:58 · View Count 601

28
20

Join the Board and leave a comment.

PlayoGuard helps keep the community healthy.

Lv.1

파코파코​

Berserk, huh? You've got great taste... Just like during that last balance game, it seems our tastes align quite a bit. I was really disappointed with Tokyo Ghoul, though. Do you have any other masterpieces you'd recommend? ♩

1
2026.11.10 PM 2:01

KeeperOfMemories

Lv.38

비트플로우

I... Blue Lock Season 2... there was a lot of talk about the legendary 'PPT' 🫪 Even though it felt like a last-minute gamble, it wasn't perfect. But I do think the manga definitely has better impact and art style 👍

3
2026.11.10 PM 2:03

PlayioVeteran

Lv.75

fluster00pp

Nahia's original art style is really pretty.

2
2026.11.10 PM 2:09

CommunityDweller

Lv.93

mintmint

Most detailed art is like that lol

2
2026.11.10 PM 2:13

Gamer

Lv.33

scheasz

It kinda reminds me of Black Butler lol, and Pandora Hearts too hahaha. I heard that even the Japanese fandom pretty much pretends the Pandora Hearts anime doesn't exist, treating it like a dark history lol. It's an old anime, sure, but even for an old anime, the art and story were... The original manga is seriously amazing though lololol T_T As for Black Butler... what's there to even say? lol. They pretty much ruined the anime from mid-Season 1 to Season 2 with all original episodes (?), although Season 3, Book of Circus, and the movie, Book of Atlantic, followed the original story, which was better. But the anime that came after... even considering it's modern animation, I'm like 'what is this even?', the art style is just so hard to get used to. I'm left thinking, 'Was this the best they could do...?' and concluding that the original manga is the way to go... lololol T_T

2
2026.11.10 PM 2:28

TipBlackHole

Lv.103

루카루카

Oh, I thought My Hero Academia was similar, but I guess not lololol I strangely feel like they're all the same ㅠㅠ

1
2026.11.10 PM 2:49

RNGGod

Lv.49

영햇

Sakamoto Days and Kaiju No. 8. The original art is really beautiful... the anime though... ㅠㅠ

2
2026.11.10 PM 2:50

Lv.74

에이포용지

I guess most people feel the original manga was better because I prefer manga...

3
2026.11.10 PM 3:03

This comment has been deleted.


KeeperOfMemories

Lv.74

ht0917

The anime adaptations of Demon Slayer and My Hero Academia are based on the original manga...

3
2026.11.10 PM 3:24

Lv.59

나이오스

One Dance

1
2026.11.10 PM 7:41

PlayioVeteran

Lv.52

YUBIO

I prefer Sakamoto Days because the original manga's contrast and shading are artistic.

1
(Modified)2026.11.11 AM 4:39

KeeperOfMemories

Lv.30

brackdanmuzi

If there was a 'subculture game', one comes to mind lol. If you're talking about manga adaptations, aren't they just low-quality, mass-produced isekai anime? Many of them have poor animation.

1
2026.11.11 AM 5:51