PlayioPlayio
Go back
​思辨實驗室
TipTycoon
Lv.19

曼陀羅

If AI calculates that you will commit murder tomorrow, should you be arrested today?

Debate Topic: To achieve zero crime, can the state preemptively arrest individuals who are 'predicted to commit crimes in the future'? Scenario: 'Those self-righteous human rights advocates again,' Officer Andrews scoffed, watching the protesters outside the courthouse with a cynical smile. Once upon a time, this city's safety was legendary. After she fully implemented the 'Predictive Sentencing Program,' murder rates plummeted by 90%, and robberies and other street crimes decreased by over 80%. This new system, authorized by law, uses highly sophisticated AI and big data algorithms to accurately predict who will commit what crime in the future. The police would then arrest potential offenders through random sampling or targeted surveillance before they could act, subjecting them to mandatory rehabilitation. In Andrews's eyes, the system wasn't harsh. Most rehabilitation sentences didn't exceed a year. Compared to letting them commit murder and face life imprisonment, this intervention not only saved potential victims' lives but also offered these 'pre-criminals' a chance to reform. Yet, today, she found herself on trial because of this very program. The slogan 'You can't punish a crime that hasn't happened' was overwhelming, and her past achievements could be ruined at any moment. Staring at the noisy crowd outside through the car window, Andrews thought to herself: 'Among these people shouting for freedom, how many will be flagged by the system as future offenders?' Question: 'Is it not a crime if it didn't happen?' If someone is merely 'calculated to commit murder in the future' but hasn't taken any action, is it reasonable to arrest and detain them immediately?

關起來!他會犯罪的!
5
放了他!他根本沒做!
22

2026.11.18 PM 5:24 · View Count 557

10
22

Join the Board and leave a comment.

PlayoGuard helps keep the community healthy.
Pioneer

Lv.74

月華流觴

No way🙅 You can prevent it, but you can't pre-judge... See with your actions, not your heart.

2
2026.11.18 AM 9:30

Gamer

Lv.5

蚵仔煎愛好者

🤔

1
2026.11.18 AM 10:50

Lv.20

Arec

Isn't this the plot of the movie 'Minority Report'~?

2
2026.11.18 AM 10:53

Lv.2

shya

🧐

1
2026.11.18 PM 12:04

Newbie

Lv.47

森嵐

Shouldn't 'punishment' that occurs before a crime even happens be considered a crime itself? Since it's a world where AI is constantly monitoring and evaluating, why not divide risk levels and deploy enforcement capabilities to stop crimes in real-time for high-risk individuals? AI can definitely do that. In a world constantly evaluated by AI, there should be no privacy, and no one would object to being monitored, right?

2
2026.11.18 PM 12:51

Patient

Lv.6

qwe306989168

It's different.

1
2026.11.18 PM 3:36